REPORT TO COUNCIL
SUBJECT
Title
Action on the Award of an Agreement for Services to Thermal Mechanical, Inc. for HVAC Restoration Services at the Senior Center Natatorium for a Not-To-Exceed Amount of $448,139, and Approval of Related Budget Amendment
Report
BACKGROUND
The Senior Center Natatorium’s Heating, Ventilation, and Air Conditioning (HVAC) system was installed approximately 20 years ago and experienced its first major failure in 2021. Since then, the system has experienced multiple significant failures, and its condition has continued to deteriorate, affecting overall reliability and performance. The HVAC is critical to maintaining appropriate temperature, humidity, and air quality conditions within the Natatorium, ensuring a safe and comfortable environment for patrons and staff.
Natatorium facilities operate under unique environmental conditions due to the presence of chloramines generated through pool water treatment processes. Without adequate ventilation, chloramines can accumulate within the facility, resulting in poor indoor air quality, accelerated corrosion of building systems and equipment, and potential health and safety concerns. As a result, natatorium HVAC equipment and replacement components must be specially designed to withstand prolonged exposure to elevated chloramine concentrations and cannot be readily substituted with standard commercial HVAC equipment.
The existing HVAC system is planned for full replacement as a part of a future, multi-phase Capital Improvement Project. The project is anticipated to begin with the design phase in approximately two years, followed by construction. Based on the current project schedule, completion of the HVAC replacement is expected within approximately five years.
To maintain safe and reliable facility operations until the replacement project is complete, staff recommends undertaking significant repairs of the existing system, including in-kind replacement of critical components. This interim measure is intended to reduce the risk of future system failures, support continued delivery of recreational services, and protect the health and safety of patrons and staff.
DISCUSSION
Pursuant to Section 2.105.140(c) of the City of Santa Clara City Code, a formal Request for Proposals (RFP) for HVAC repair and maintenance services for the Senior Center Natatorium was conducted, with the award recommendation based on “best value”. The RFP sought qualified firms to perform significant restoration of the existing HVAC system and provide ongoing preventative maintenance services to extend the system’s useful life until the planned system replacement is completed. For City procurement and contracting purposes, the requested repair and maintenance services fall within the definition of “General Services” under Section 2.105.010 (e)(1)(A) of the City Code, which includes maintenance and nonstructural repair and improvements to City buildings and structures that do not require engineering plans, specifications, or design. Accordingly, the procurement was conducted through the City’s formal RFP process applicable to General Services.
Separately, for California labor-compliance purposes, the City determined that the services constitute a “public work” subject to the prevailing wages requirements of California Labor Code Section 1770 et seq. Proposers were required to hold a valid C-20 Warm-Air Heating, Ventilating and Air-Conditioning license and to be registered with the Department of Industrial Relations.
The RFP was published on the City’s e-procurement system, which notified 466 vendors, and staff also conducted direct outreach to firms. Three firms attended the mandatory pre-proposal conference. By the proposal due date, the City received one proposal from Thermal Mechanical. Following the solicitation, staff contacted the two firms that attended the pre-proposal conference but did not submit proposals to better understand the limited response. One firm did not respond to the City’s inquiry, while the other indicated that internal timing constraints prevented it from participating in the solicitation. Based on the outreach conducted, the limited response is believed to reflect the specialized nature of natatorium HVAC systems, the limited number of firms with the expertise and manufacturer support necessary to perform the required repairs and maintenance, and vendor resource constraints.
Staff evaluated the proposed pricing and determined it to be fair and reasonable based on the specialized nature of the equipment, the complexity of the work, and current market conditions. Unlike conventional commercial HVAC systems, natatorium HVAC units are specifically engineered to operate in high-humidity, chloramine-intensive environments and require specialized temperature, humidity, and ventilation controls. These unique operating conditions significantly limit the number of qualified manufacturers, suppliers, and contractors capable of providing compatible equipment, replacement components, and maintenance services.
Thermal Mechanical has partnered with Dectron, the original manufacturer of the HVAC system, to perform the restoration and in-kind replacement of critical components necessary to restore the system to the highest practical level of functionality. Because the system has experienced multiple failures, isolated repairs would not adequately address the underlying reliability issues. Instead, the proposed work includes the repair or replacement of numerous critical mechanical and electrical components, including compressors, fan motors, evaporator coils, control panels, boiler ignitors, pumps, and other system components essential to reliable operation.
The total cost of the restoration is $351,482, which includes $296,642 for specialized parts and labor, $22,330 for labor by Thermal Mechanical, $18,600 for crane services required to remove and install rooftop equipment, $12,646 for specialized surface epoxy coating, and $1,264 for delivery, freight, disposal, and miscellaneous parts and tax. The scope also includes comprehensive testing, startup, and commissioning of the system to verify proper operation. The agreement requires substantial completion within 90 calendar days and final completion within 120 calendar days after the date specified in the Notice to Proceed, and provides for liquidated damages of $500 per day for delay.
The proposed agreement includes a 25% contingency not-to-exceed $87,870 to address unforeseen conditions and additional repairs identified during the restoration. The higher contingency is warranted due to the age of the system and the likelihood that additional repairs may be required as components are inspected, repaired, or replaced. Any use of contingency funding requires the City’s express prior written authorization through an executed change order. The proposed agreement also includes $8,787 to cover the cost of City required payment and performance bonds. In total, the total not-to-exceed amount for restoration services, bond costs, and contingency funding is
$448,139.
A summary of all costs associated with the HVAC restoration project is provided below.
Table 1 - HVAC Restoration Project Costs
|
Item |
Cost |
|
HVAC Restoration (Exhibit C, Sec. 1) |
$351,482 |
|
Bonds at 2.5% of Restoration Costs (Exhibit C, Sec. 2) |
$8,787 |
|
25% Contingency (Exhibit C, Sec. 3) |
$87,870 |
|
Maximum Not-To-Exceed Amount (Agreement Sec. 3.7.1) |
$448,139 |
Staff compared this approach with full replacement of the unit, which would involve additional engineering and structural evaluations, integration with the existing building systems, roofing modifications, controls integration, and associated construction activities to ensure the new unit is properly connected and operational, with an estimated cost of at least $750,000. While these engineering and construction requirements would not be as extensive as those associated with the future facility-wide HVAC Capital Improvement Project, they would nevertheless add complexity, time, and cost to the replacement. Given that a comprehensive facility-wide HVAC replacement is already planned as part of a future Capital Improvement Project, investing in a full replacement of the existing unit at this time would not be a prudent use of public funds. Accordingly, staff finds the proposed pricing to be fair and reasonable, as it provides a practical and cost-effective interim solution to maintain safe and reliable operation of the Natatorium until the planned capital replacement project can be completed.
Following completion of the restoration, the City anticipates entering into a separate services agreement based on the same competitive procurement process as the HVAC restoration project with Thermal Mechanical to provide bi-monthly preventative maintenance services to help ensure continued system reliability and performance. These services will include inspections of major system components, boiler operations, drainage systems, refrigeration equipment, and compressor fans. In addition, the services would require Thermal Mechanical to perform a joint annual preventive maintenance service with Dectron that includes comprehensive system cleaning, belt replacement, inspection of electrical components, filter replacement, controls calibration, and operational testing.
ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW
This project being considered is exempt from the California Environmental Quality Act (“CEQA”) pursuant to CEQA Guidelines section 15301 (c), “Existing Facilities,” as the activity consists of the repair, maintenance or minor alteration of existing facilities involving no or negligible expansion of the use beyond that presently existing. This project being considered is also exempt from CEQA pursuant to Section 15302 (c) “Replacement or Reconstruction”, since it involves reconstruction of an existing facility involving negligible or no expansion of capacity.
FISCAL IMPACT
The agreement with Thermal Mechanical has a not-to-exceed amount of $448,139 (Agreement Section 3.7.1) consisting of $351,482 for the HVAC restoration, a 25% contingency of $87,870, and funding for performance bonds of $8,787. Any use of contingency funding requires an executed change order.
The Senior Center Natatorium HVAC Project in the Parks and Recreation Capital Fund has an FY 26/27 budget of $172,500 to perform a comprehensive assessment of the facility’s condition and support future renovations, including the HVAC restoration. Staff recommends applying this existing funding toward the proposed restoration effort. The remaining $275,639 required to fully fund the agreement, including contingency and bond costs, is recommended to be appropriated from the Mitigation Fee Act (MFA) fund balance.
MFA fees are restricted to parks and recreation facilities that serve new residential development or the community generally. The City’s 2019 Parks and Recreation Facilities Fee Study (Fee Study), which supports the current MFA fee, identifies the fees for use on a citywide network of parks and recreation facilities and includes the Santa Clara Senior Center in the inventory of existing recreation facilities on which the MFA park improvement fee is based. The Senior Center is a citywide facility, and its natatorium is one of five public aquatic sites in the City, so it serves residents of new development throughout Santa Clara rather than a single neighborhood.
Since the Fee Study’s 2018 base year, the City’s population has grown from 126,408 to an estimated 133,597 residents (2023), and it is projected to reach 154,569 by 2038. Residents age 55 and older, the Senior Center’s primary users, grew from 19% to 24% of the population between 2010 and 2023. Use of the Senior Center Natatorium has grown to the limit of its current programming. Aquatic fitness classes operated at approximately 95 percent of capacity in FY 2025/26, up from 86 percent in FY 2024/25, and waitlist requests tripled from 41 to 129 over the same period. Classes in FY 2026/27 to date have operated at 98 percent of capacity. From July 2024 through October 2026, the Senior Center’s 2,894 Premium members, who have access to the Natatorium and Fitness Center, recorded more than 175,000 facility entries. Staff has found that new residential development is contributing to this increased demand; Premium members include residents of North Santa Clara (ZIP code 95054), an area of significant recent residential development, who accounted for approximately 11,700 of these entries. The condition of the HVAC system has also limited the number of aquatic classes Recreation is able to offer. Government Code Section 66001(g) allows impact fees to fund the refurbishment of existing facilities to maintain the existing level of service where the need is attributable to increased demand from new development. The proposed restoration maintains the Natatorium’s existing level of service for this growing service population. It does not physically expand the facility; rather, restoring reliable HVAC operation will allow Recreation, together with planned aquatics staffing, to offer additional classes within the existing pools to meet this demand. The work is also consistent with the City’s adopted Capital Improvement Program, which includes the Senior Center Natatorium HVAC Project, and with the 2026 Parks and Recreation Master Plan, which recommends evaluating and upgrading the Senior Center’s HVAC systems.
Following completion of the restoration, ongoing preventative maintenance of the HVAC system will be provided under a separate services agreement. The annual cost of these maintenance services will be absorbed within the Parks and Recreation Department’s operating budget, and no Mitigation Fee Act funds or additional appropriation are requested for maintenance.
The recommended budget actions are summarized below.
Budget Amendment
FY 2026/27
|
Parks and Recreation Capital Fund |
Current |
Increase/ (Decrease) |
Revised |
|
|
|
Expenditures |
|
|
|
|
Senior Center Natatorium HVAC Project |
$172,500 |
$275,639 |
$448,139 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Ending Fund Balance |
|
|
|
|
Fund Balance - Mitigation Fee Act Fees |
$17,071,259 |
($275,639) |
$16,795,620 |
COORDINATION
This report has been coordinated with the Parks and Recreation Department, the Finance Department, the Public Works Department, the City Attorney’s Office, and the City Manager’s Office.
PUBLIC CONTACT
Public contact was made by posting the Council agenda on the City’s official-notice bulletin board outside City Hall Council Chambers. A complete agenda packet is available on the City’s website and in the City Clerk’s Office at least 72 hours prior to a Regular Meeting and 24 hours prior to a Special Meeting. A hard copy of any agenda report may be requested by contacting the City Clerk’s Office at (408) 615-2220, email clerk@santaclaraca.gov or at the public information desk at any City of Santa Clara public library.
RECOMMENDATION
Recommendation
1. Authorize the City Manager or designee to execute an agreement with Thermal Mechanical, Inc. for HVAC restoration services at the Senior Center Natatorium for a total maximum compensation amount of $448,139, subject to the appropriation of funds;
2. Authorize the City Manager or designee take any actions as necessary to implement and administer the agreement, including to (a) add or delete services consistent with the scopes of services, and (b) make de minimis changes, provided that the total maximum compensation amount is not exceeded, subject to the appropriation of funds and approval as to form by the City Attorney; and
3. Approve the FY 2026/27 budget amendment in the Parks and Recreation Capital Fund to increase the Senior Center Natatorium HVAC Project appropriation by $275,639 and decrease the Mitigation Fee Act Fees ending fund balance by $275,639 (five affirmative Council votes required for the use of unused balances).
Staff
Reviewed by: Damon Sparacino, Director, Parks & Recreation
Approved by: Jovan Grogan, City Manager
ATTACHMENTS
1. Agreement - CSC - Thermal Mechanical - HVAC Restoration